Wednesday, November 18, 2020

Paul McCartney & Wings - One Hand Clapping

 Paul McCartney & Wings – One Hand Clapping
(soniclovenoize reconstruction)

Side A:
1. One Hand Clapping
2. Jet
3. Let Me Roll It
4. Junior’s Farm
5. My Love

Side B:
6. Little Woman Love/C Moon
7. Maybe I’m Amazed
8. Band On The Run
9. Wild Life
10. Hi Hi Hi

Side C:
1. Live and Let Die
2. Soily
3. Go Now
4. Blue Moon of Kentucky
5. Bluebird

Side D:
6. Suicide
7. Let’s Love
8. Sitting At The Piano/All Of You
9. I’ll Give You A Ring
10. Baby Face
11. Blackbird
12. Country Dreamer
13. Nineteen Hundred and Eighty-Five

My how time flies! Why is the pandemic not over yet!? Sorry for the delay, but it’s finally here-- the second of a trilogy of famous live albums that never were, in memory of the live music we can’t quite yet experience again. This is a reconstruction of the proposed 1974 live in-the-Abbey Road studio album One Hand Clapping by Paul McCartney & Wings. Originally meant as the studio rehearsals for a 1974 Wings Over Australia tour that never happened, the proceedings were filmed for a possible film release, akin to The Beatles’ Get Back project eight years earlier. Despite the high quality of live studio performances—especially of the then-unreleased “Soily”--McCartney shelved the entire project, as was the fate of a number of other self-financed Wings film projects throughout the 70s and 80s. This reconstruction attempts to replicate what a double-LP release in 1974 could have been like, using the best possible sources, including official releases and painstakingly-remastered bootleg recordings. All tracks have been sequenced in the actual recording order, spread across four sides of a vinyl record.

The arrival of Band on The Run signaled a few changes in Paul McCartney & Wings. Firstly, it was McCartney’s first post-Beatles “masterpiece album”, finally equaling the quality of a typical Beatles album. Miraculously, the album was a product of the trio of Paul, Linda McCartney and Denny Laine, as drummer Denny Seiwell and guitarist Henry McCullough quit the band just before the start of the album’s recording sessions. This eventually led to the second major change for Wings: a new line-up. A month before Band On The Run’s December 1973 release, Wings broke in their new guitarist Jimmy McCulloch by recording some of Linda’s songs as Suzy and The Red Stripes, as well as a session for Paul’s brother Michael, as McGear, in February 1974.

Wings finally recruited drummer Geoff Britton and headed to Nashville in July to rehearse for a planned tour of Australia. While they were there, Wings also recorded the single “Junior’s Farm” (one of this author’s favorite Wings songs) as well as a handful of country-tinged tracks under the name The Country Hams. Rehearsals for the theoretical tour continued across the ocean in late August at McCartney’s old stomp: Abbey Road studios! But McCartney thought a little more of these activities than just simply rehearsals, as he employed boy-genius engineer Geoff Emerick to record the session, as well as David Litchfield to film and direct the sessions for a possible documentary film release.

The first day of rehearsals on August 26th produced full-band versions of “Jet”, “Let Me Roll It”, “Junior’s Farm”, “My Love”, “Little Woman Love”/”C Moon”, “Maybe I’m Amazed” and a short instrumental jam which would become the theme song for the project: “One Hand Clapping”. The second day of recording produced takes of “Band On The Run”, “Wild Life”, “Hi Hi Hi”, “Live and Let Die”, “Soily”, “Go Now”, “Blue Moon of Kentucky” and “Bluebird.” Day three of recording saw Paul performing a number of songs alone at the piano, which has posthumously been dubbed “The Cabaret Sequence.” Paul went though supposedly impromptu performances of “Suicide”, “Let’s Love”, “All of You,” “I’ll Give You a Ring” and a ‘proper’ take of “Baby Face.”

Day four saw the entire band returning to the studio to add overdubs to the live tracks recorded on the 26th and the 27th: “My Love”, “Live and Let Die”, “Band On The Run” “Bluebird” and “Jet”. August 30th, the fifth and final day of recording, was a unique staging meant as an interlude segment in the One Hand Clapping film: a solo acoustic performance by Paul in the backyard of Abbey Road studios! Although Paul again drifted through several impromptu takes of a number of classic 1950s rock songs, he did record fairly complete takes of Beatles classic “Blackbird”, the then-unreleased Wings b-side “Country Dreamer” and the as-yet unreleased “Blackpool.” Afterwards, Paul retreated back into Studio Two to track a tight solo piano version of “Eighteen Hundred and Eighty-Five”, which mysteriously morphs into the Band On The Run studio version in the actual unreleased One Hand Clapping film, as well as all known audio recordings.

And that was essentially the last anyone heard of One Hand Clapping, aside from archival releases and bootlegs of varying quality. While the film was completed later in 1975, it was never released; Paul had a tendency to finance vanity projects himself, comfortable with leaving them in the vault, such as the animated Bruce McMouse Show which did not see release until 46 years later! This line-up of Wings eventually returned to Abbey Road in November to start work on their next album, Venus and Mars, recording a handful of songs: “Rock Show”, “Love In Song”, “Letting Go” and “Medicine Jar.” Needing a change of scenery, Wings relocated to New Orleans in early 1975, where Britton exited the Wings due to personal disagreements with the bands’ guitarists. Joe English was hired as a session drummer to finish the album and was later asked to join Wings when the album was completed. Venus and Mars was released in May to critical and commercial success.

But what of the missing live-in-studio One Hand Clapping? Only “Baby Face” received overdubs during the Venus and Mars sessions—a New Orleans jazz band—presumably for possible b-side inclusion. While the film made it’s rounds on the bootleg circuit and eventually as a bonus on the 2010 Band On The Run box set, various tracks have trickled out on archival releases over the years, as well as it’s presumed entirety on various bootlegs. For this reconstruction, we will cull all of these sources and piece together as much as we are able to—including the live between-song banter, which is essential to the spirit of these recordings. All sources from bootlegs have been painstakingly remastered to match the fidelity of the pristine officially-released tracks, and all of the songs are presented mostly in the order of witch they were recorded, as per Chip Madinger and Mark Easter’s excellent Eight Arms To Hold You: The Solo Beatles Compendium. We will also use only the two most complete songs from Paul’s “Backyard Session”, as the goal here is to present a facsimile commercial double LP that could have been released in late 1974 in lieu of a Band On The Run tour.

Side A begins with the theme of the film and the title track, “One Hand Clapping”, taken from Yellow Cat’s fantastic One Hand Clapping bootleg, the best quality boot of the band-sessions. Following is “Jet” and “Let Me Roll It” from the 2010 Band On The Run box set, with the studio banter restored from the bootlegs. “Junior’s Farm” and “My Love” follow, both taken from the Yellow Cat bootleg. Side B fades in with the medley of “Little Woman Love” and “C Moon” from the Yellow Cat bootleg, followed by “Maybe I’m Amazed” from the 2011 box set for McCartney. Next is “Band On The Run”, again taken from the 2010 Band On The Run box, followed by a fraction of “Wild Life” and a roaring “Hi Hi Hi”, both from the Yellow Cat bootleg, to close out the first disc.

Disc two begins with “Live and Let Die”, taken from The In-Laws soundtrack. Next is the fantastic studio take of “Soily” that was never released, as well as Denny Laine’s “Go Now” and Paul’s go-to cover, “Blue Moon of Kentucky”, all taken from the Yellow Cat bootleg. We end the side with the final full-band recording of One Hand Clapping, “Bluebird” from the 2010 Band On The Run box. I chose to condense all of the Cabaret Sequence and Backyard Sessions together on Side D, starting with only the Cabaret material shown in the film. Using the bootleg MoMac’s Hidden Tracks Vol 7 as the source for the core, I patched in the proper demo of “Let’s Love” from 2014 Venus and Mars box set, which was presumably recorded during the One Hand Clapping sessions. Ending the sequence is “Baby Face”, again from the 2014 Venus and Mars box, featuring overdubs anachronistically recorded 1975 for this presumed 1974 release. Since nothing from The Backyard Sessions actually made the cut into the One Hand Clapping documentary, I will simply include the two most complete takes of “Blackbird” and “Country Dreamer”, with dialog edited to give the illusion that and random passerby had requested the songs. The album closes with “Nineteen Hundred and Eighty-Five” taken from the 2010 Band on the Run box; instead of segueing into the album version of the “Band On The Run” coda fade, I have used the early live version for continuity.

Special thanks to Mark Heggen for making the awesome cover artwork-- something that One Hand Clapping never had in any iteration!

Sources used:
Band On The Run (2010 Deluxe Edition)
The In-Laws (soundtrack, 2003)
One Hand Clapping (bootleg, Yellow Cat Records, 1994)
McCartney (2011 Deluxe Edition)
MoMac’s Hidden Tracks Vol 7 (bootleg, 2002)
Venus and Mars (2014 Deluxe Edition)

flac --> wav --> editing in SONAR Pro and Goldwave --> flac encoding via TLH lv8
* md5 files, track notes and artwork included


  1. Great choice, and welcomed after a long wait. Excited to give this a listen. Thanks for your consistently amazing work.

  2. This looks particularly great, Sonic - and welcome back with a vengeance!

  3. That's great!!! Thank you so much, you really made my day :-)

  4. Superb! Great quality and always a joy to read your extensive and excellent notes on these Sonic. Appreciated, this is fab!

  5. Thanks for your hard work Sonic!

  6. Thanks for this, and for all the work you put into it! One note: "Country Dreamer" was the B-side of "Helen Wheels", so it had seen release (though not in the States) by the time OHC was made. I always think of it as the Ringo to "Let Me Roll It"'s John and "No Words"'s George, and so I remember it as Ringo only getting the b-side, rather than a place on the record!

  7. Love the concept/arrangement and the remastering is fantastic, but using the over-pronounced and under-performed take of Soily is a collosal oversight IMO. Using the lesser take of Jet I can forgive since that was the one officially released, but Soily's superior take was also officially released and is therefore a glaring omission. Not to say I don't appreciate your hard work on this because I definitely do, but that's just what I feel holds it back from being a perfect reconstruction. Cheers Sonic, appreciate the post.

    1. Wow, completely disagree! I loved the takes of Soily and Jet that I used, and thought the others were a bit subpar. To each his own, I guess.

  8. This sounds great, Sonic! ESPECIALLY the "Soily". Best version of OHC I've yet heard, and as always, such a nice presentation. Wish Apple would just hire you already.

  9. Welcome were sorely missed! Great post!!

  10. This is great man! Was listening to a bootleg of this the other day and was wondering if this one was in your arsenal! A pleasant pandemic surprise!

  11. While I'm aware of One Hand Clapping, I've never dug into it beyond a few bonus tracks on recent reissues. But I've been spinning this reconstruction for the last 3 days straight and it's terrific - a real lost classic. Thank you!!

  12. Welcome back, very cool as per usual. Nice post.

  13. This is wonderful! Thank you so much.

  14. Great as usual, thank you for this!

  15. One question. Where does "Sally G" fit into any of this?

    1. It doesn't. It was recorded along with the single version of "Junior's Farm", earlier that year.

  16. Maybe recorded right here?

    1. Correct. They recorded Sally G, Junior's Farm and The Country Ham single there.

    2. Hey soniclovenoize can I put in a request for Kiss’ lost album from 1978 assembled from their four solo albums?

  17. Ab Fab!! Thank you SO much for this. Great work and welcome back!


  18. Your work continues to inspire me and get me through these harder than ever times. This one is a delight. I love your posts because they tend to be in one of two categories, albums or mythical albums I am super familiar and obsessed with or ones that are obscure to me which I then have the pleasure of reading deeply about and listening to source material and coming to for the first time. It's a good format you have. This was just say hello and thank you and I'm guessing you've heard this one a million times but how about a closer to Elliott's vision version of "From a Basement on the Hill"?

  19. I'm not sure what your third live album is going to be...but it's going to be very difficult to beat this one. Many, many thanks!

  20. Dear Sonic, thank you me aswell for your dedicasion. Listening to your (upgraded) Get Back Album as I am writing this.
    As for my request; in 1987 Paul recorded songs for a new project to follow up "Press To Play". They are available on the Bootleg called "Return To Pepperland", some of those recordings found their way to B-sides of Flaming Pie singles. Can you investigate if there is a missing album amongst that material?
    Thank you in advance.

  21. Hello Sonic, I’ve got a request for the next live album that never was: I’m recently trying to recreate the complete live performance by Pink Floyd at the Empire Pool in 1974. The tracks are all officially released in high quality (they can be found in the Immersion box sets of DSOTM and WYWH and in the Early Years one) but I think they need more “coherence” between them, maybe a little bit of EQ or something to make it feel more like a real official release... do you think you can make it? It would be AWESOME! Btw thank you for your amazing work, I love your reconstructed albums!

  22. Hello, everybody! Can't find the link to that beauty!

  23. empty3


    1. the above links are for the mp3 and flac versions respectively. Looking forward to hearing it, love all your stuff.

  24. You're a genious, Sonic. Simple as that.

  25. This is one I’ve always wanted!

  26. I'm so excited to hear this. Thank you for making yet another "lost" album!